Stay interviews: Comprehensive guidance

Dr Richard Dune

20-12-2024

Stay interviews: Comprehensive guidance

Image by AnnaStills via Envato Elements

Unlocking the power of stay interviews: A comprehensive guide to retain, engage, and empower your workforce

In today’s competitive job market, retaining top talent and maintaining high levels of employee engagement are critical to organisational success. Stay interviews are emerging as a proactive and cost-effective strategy to achieve these goals. Unlike exit interviews, which focus on why employees leave, stay interviews concentrate on why employees stay and what can be done to ensure their continued satisfaction and growth.

In this comprehensive guide, Dr Richard Dune explores everything you need to know about stay interviews, including their definition, benefits, best practices, and actionable steps for implementation. We will also provide examples, templates, and tips to make your stay interviews effective and impactful.

What are stay interviews?

A stay interview is a structured, one-on-one conversation between a manager and an employee to uncover the factors that keep the employee engaged and satisfied in their role. It also identifies potential issues or challenges that, if left unaddressed, could lead to disengagement or turnover.

Unlike employee surveys or exit interviews, stay interviews offer real-time insights into the employee experience. They allow organisations to take timely, tailored actions to improve engagement and retention. The focus is on personalised solutions rather than generic data collection, making these conversations invaluable for fostering trust and collaboration.

Benefits of stay interviews

Stay interviews are a powerful tool for improving workplace satisfaction and retention. By proactively addressing employee needs and concerns, organisations can foster stronger engagement, build trust, and implement meaningful changes that benefit employees and the business.

Enhances employee retention

Stay interviews help organisations identify and resolve potential issues before they lead to resignations. This proactive approach significantly reduces turnover and strengthens the organisation’s ability to retain top talent.

Boosts engagement

By focusing on employees’ motivations, needs, and aspirations, stay interviews create an opportunity for managers to make meaningful improvements in the workplace. Engaged employees are more productive, committed, and likely to contribute positively to the company culture.

Builds trust and loyalty

When managers genuinely listen to employees and act on their feedback, it fosters a sense of trust and loyalty. Employees feel valued and are more likely to remain committed to the organisation.

Promotes collaboration

Stay interviews focus on idea-sharing and problem-solving. Employees and managers work together to identify areas for improvement, strengthening the team dynamic and fostering a culture of collaboration.

Provides actionable insights

Unlike static surveys, stay interviews allow for follow-up questions and deeper exploration of topics. This personalised approach yields actionable insights that are directly relevant to individual employees and the organisation as a whole.

Improves organisational policies

Patterns and trends identified during stay interviews can inform broader organisational changes. For example, recurring feedback about work-life balance might lead to implementing flexible working policies.

Cost-effective solution

Stay interviews require minimal resources compared to the high costs of recruitment and onboarding new employees. They provide a significant return on investment by reducing turnover and improving engagement.

Stay interviews vs. Exit interviews

While stay interviews and exit interviews both focus on understanding employee experiences, their timing, purpose, and outcomes differ significantly.

By conducting stay interviews, organisations can address concerns early and avoid the need for exit interviews altogether.

Best practices for conducting stay interviews

To ensure stay interviews are effective and meaningful, approach them with thoughtful preparation and a focus on open, constructive dialogue. Click the tabs below to reveal the essential do's and don'ts to guide the process.

Do’s of stay interviews

Prepare thoroughly

To address employee concerns, Equip managers with a clear structure, well-crafted questions, and knowledge of available organisational resources.

Create a comfortable setting

Choose a private and relaxed environment where employees feel safe to share openly.

Focus on listening

Dedicate 80% of the conversation to listening, allowing employees to express themselves fully without interruptions.

Probe for deeper insights

Use follow-up questions to better understand the employee’s responses.

Follow through

Communicate the actions being taken based on employee feedback and explain why certain changes may not be feasible.

Don’ts of stay interviews

Don’t treat it like a performance review

Avoid evaluating the employee’s performance during the stay interview. Focus solely on their experience and needs.

Don’t make empty promises

Be transparent about what changes can and cannot be implemented.

Don’t generalise

Conduct individual interviews to ensure personalised feedback and solutions.

Don’t get defensive

Accept criticism gracefully and use it as an opportunity for improvement.

Don’t make it a one-time activity

Conduct stay interviews periodically to keep a pulse on employee satisfaction.

Key questions for stay interviews

The following five questions, complemented by probing techniques, can guide meaningful and effective stay interviews:

What do you look forward to most when you come to work?

Helps identify what employees value most about their roles and workplace.

What are you learning here, and what would you like to learn?

Provides insights into professional development needs and aspirations.

Why do you stay here?

Encourages employees to reflect on the positive aspects of their job, reinforcing their commitment.

When was the last time you thought about leaving, and what prompted it?

Brings to light potential issues or triggers that may lead to disengagement.

What can I do to make your job better for you?

Opens the door for constructive feedback and actionable solutions.

Stay interview template

A well-structured template for stay interviews ensures meaningful and consistent conversations, helping managers capture valuable insights effectively. Below is a practical framework to guide the process:

Agenda for a stay interview

Introduction

Begin by explaining the purpose of the meeting.
Reassure the employee that their feedback is valued and will inform actionable changes.

Discussion topics

Motivators - What inspires you to come to work each day?
Challenges - Are there any obstacles or frustrations affecting your job satisfaction?
Growth opportunities - What new skills or experiences would you like to develop in your role?
Support needs - How can I better support you in achieving your goals?
Improvements - What changes could enhance your work environment or overall experience?

Closing

Summarise the key points discussed during the interview.
Outline the next steps and provide a timeline for any follow-up actions.
Thank the employee for their honesty and participation.

Examples of organisational changes sparked by stay interviews

Stay interviews can drive impactful organisational improvements. Here are a few examples:

Flexible work policies - Feedback about the need for better work-life balance led to the introduction of hybrid and flexible work arrangements.
Professional development programmes - Employee aspirations for growth inspired the creation of mentoring initiatives and skill-building workshops.
Recognition initiatives - Suggestions for more frequent appreciation resulted in monthly awards and peer recognition systems.

This refined process not only strengthens employee engagement but also helps organisations address key retention challenges with targeted solutions.

Final Thoughts

Stay interviews are a powerful tool for retaining top talent, improving employee engagement, and fostering trust within teams. By proactively addressing concerns and enhancing the employee experience, organisations can build a loyal and motivated workforce prepared to thrive. The insights gained from stay interviews strengthen individual relationships and inform strategic organisational changes that drive long-term success.

Take the next step with our leadership training programmes

Ready to elevate your leadership skills and unlock the full potential of your team? We offer a wide range of CPDUK-accredited online leadership and management training courses alongside Leadership Mastery, our comprehensive online subscription library of courses and resources for leaders and managers.

All our training is externally peer-reviewed and accredited by the CPD Certification Service. Discover how our courses can confidently help you lead and drive meaningful results.

About the author

Dr Richard Dune

With over 20 years of experience, Dr Richard Dune blends a rich background in NHS, the private sector, academia, and research settings. His forte lies in clinical R&D, advancing healthcare tech, workforce development and governance. His leadership ensures regulatory compliance and innovation align seamlessly.